Chapter 1 - Introduction
Background to the inquiry
1.1
Recently, a number of high profile cases have raised
questions about the response and responsiveness of the government to vulnerable
people either asking for or relying on the Australian government to provide
protection and/or assistance. This report examines two such cases.
1.2
First, Mr Chen Yonglin, a Chinese diplomat working at
the Chinese Consulate in Sydney who approached the Department of Immigration,
Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (DIMIA) on 26 May 2005 to request
political asylum for himself and his wife and daughter. Questions soon arose
over whether contact with the Chinese consulate by DIMIA to confirm Mr
Chen's identity on 26 May was appropriate and
this is examined in chapter two. The decision of the Minister for Foreign
Affairs to reject Mr Chen's
request for political asylum and his role in such requests are considered in
chapter three. Chapter four details the actions of and meetings with DIMIA and
the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) which took place from 27 May
to 3 June 2005. Mr Chen's
claims regarding the persecution of Falun Gong, an extensive spy network in
Australia, kidnapping allegations and the monitoring and harassment of
Australian citizens are discussed in chapter five.
1.3
The second case involved Ms
Vivian Solon
who, although an Australian citizen, was deported to the Philippines
in July 2001.
Establishment of the inquiry
Terms of reference
1.4
On 16 June
2005, the Senate, on the motion of Senator Bob
Brown, referred the following matters to the
Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade References Committee
for inquiry and report by 9 August 2005:
- The response of Department of Immigration Multicultural
and Indigenous Affairs, Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, Attorney–General's
Department and their respective Ministers to Mr Chen Yonglin's approaches or
requests to the Australian Government for asylum and/or a protection visa;
- The application of the Migration Act 1958, its regulations and guidelines concerning the
maintenance of confidentiality for any consular officials or staff (including
Mr Chen Yonglin, and any other former consular officials or staff) who were
applicants for territorial asylum and/or protection visas by Department of
Immigration Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs, Department of Foreign Affairs
and Trade and their respective Ministers;
- The involvement of the Department of Foreign Affairs
and Trade and the Minister in the deportation, search and discovery of Vivian
Solon, and;
- any related matters.
Conduct of the inquiry
1.5
The committee advertised the inquiry in The Australian on 22 June 2005 and on its website. The Committee
wrote to relevant Ministers and departments, interested individuals and groups
inviting submissions. The Committee received 9 public submissions and 1
confidential submission from a range of organisations and individuals. A list
of individuals and organisations who made a public submission or provided other
information that was authorised for publication by the Committee is an Appendix
1.
1.6
The Committee held a public
hearing in Sydney and two public hearings in Canberra. A list of witnesses who
gave evidence at the public hearings is at Appendix 2.
1.7
On 5 August
2005, at 4:45pm, over
2600 folios regarding Ms Solon
were received by the secretariat from DIMIA. It was not possible for committee
members to review the documentation prior to the scheduled hearing on 8 August 2005. The committee is
disappointed that the department was not able to more promptly assist the
committee process. It placed committee members in a situation where it was not
possible for them to be fully prepared to examine the department on some matters
central to the inquiry. The committee is concerned over the department's
conduct in this matter and this will be discussed more fully in a second report
on Ms Solon.
Due to this late and voluminous production of documents, the committee decided
that it required more time to examine the documentation and this resulted in
the committee requesting three extensions to the reporting date. On 9 August 2005, the Senate granted an
extension to its reporting date to 18
August 2005. On 18 August
2005, the committee was granted an extension until 8 September 2005. On 8 September 2005, the committee was
granted an extension until 12 September
2005.
1.8
The committee further decided to produce two separate
reports—one dealing specifically with the terms of reference addressing Mr
Chen's case and a second report covering Ms Solon which is due to be tabled on
15 September 2005.
Structure of the report
1.9
This report comprises five chapters—an introduction and
four chapters that address directly the terms of reference relevant to Mr
Chen.
Acknowledgment
1.10
The committee is grateful to, and wishes to thank, all
those who assisted with its inquiry. In particular, the committee would like to
acknowledge the work of Hansard who had to deal with a complex matter, in
camera evidence and English translations.
Navigation: Previous Page | Contents | Next Page