| 
Joint Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade 
                
                
                    Navigation: Contents | Next Page
                
                Preliminary pages
Foreword
During the period July 2008 to June 2009, the Australian
Defence Force (ADF) continued to be actively involved in operations both within
and outside Australia.  Overseas deployments, which numbered 18 in total,
included East Timor, Solomon Islands, Papua New Guinea, the Northern Indian
Ocean, Africa, the Middle East, Iraq, and Afghanistan. Defence also engaged in maritime
security operations in the South China Sea in support of regional security, supported
United Nations missions, and operated in the Gulf region and the Horn of Africa
to counter the threat of piracy. Locally, Defence performed admirably assisting
the civil authorities' response to devastating natural disasters such as the
Victorian bushfires, and floods in Queensland and New South Wales.
During the review period, Defence also released two
important policy and planning documents: the 2009 White Paper, Defending
Australia in the Asia Pacific Century: Force 2030; and the Strategic
Reform Program.  The measures and policies within these two documents
importantly harmonise the cost saving measures needed to meet Defence’s future
force structure requirements.  Simply put, without prudent fiscal management
the ADF’s future capability needs cannot be delivered or sustained. The
relationship between these two capstone pieces of work will indubitably be an
area of focus for the sub-committee in future years.  
At the public hearing into the Defence Annual Report on 30
March 2010, the Defence Sub-Committee chose to examine a broad range of Defence
issues as part of the process of accountability of government agencies to
parliament. These areas of interest included major projects, recruitment and
retention, overseas operational deployments, the Defence estate and the ADF’s
operational commitments.
The committee is well aware of the significant challenges
the ADF, and in particular the Defence Materiel Organisation (DMO), faces in
managing very complex, sensitive and technical projects. The committee also
acknowledges the importance of implementing the reforms arising from the
Mortimer review of defence procurement and sustainment released in September
2008. 
More generally, it is the committee’s view that the most
important objective for Defence is to acquire needed capability in the shortest
time practicable and at an appropriate cost.  It was therefore pleasing for the
committee to be advised at the public hearing that some previously listed
projects of concern are no longer classified as such. Conversely, the committee
also noted that there remain other projects, such as the Wedgetail Airborne Early
Warning and Control aircraft, that continue to suffer an overly protracted
delay in final acceptance. 
The Joint Strike Fighter (JSF) project remains the most
expensive single acquisition in Defence’s history.  The committee has watched
with interest the developments within the United States (US) as the US
Department of Defense struggles with the JSF development program. Noting this,
the committee will continue to monitor whether the cost and schedule buffers
built into the Australian JSF project will provide some assurance that similar
problems will not be experienced here.
Recruitment and retention of ADF personnel, an area of
concern in recent years as personnel targets consistently fell short, has seen
a substantial improvement over the review period. This is a good result and
reflects the emphasis placed by Defence in ensuring that the ADF is better
placed to meet future demands of new equipment and ongoing operational
commitments.  The committee was particularly pleased to note an increase in the
number of submariners recruited although further gains are still needed. 
The committee acknowledges the service of the men and women
of the ADF in their contribution to operations across the globe. The committee
also recognises that the ADF could not meet these operational commitments
without the support of those ADF personnel who remain behind in non-combat
roles. Lastly, and importantly, the committee is grateful of the sacrifices
endured by the families, friends and loved ones of those personnel deployed in
the maintenance of Australia’s obligations at home and abroad.
The Hon Arch Bevis MP
  Chair
of Defence Sub-Committee
Membership of the Committee
 
  | 
   Chair 
   | 
  
   Senator M Forshaw   
   | 
  
     
   | 
 
 
  | 
   Deputy Chair 
   | 
  
   The
  Hon D Hawker MP 
   | 
  
     
   | 
 
 
   | Members | 
   Senator
     M Arbib (from
       01/07/08 till 11/03/09) | 
   The
     Hon J Bishop MP (from
       11/03/09) | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator
     A Bartlett (till
       30/06/08) | 
   Mr
     M Coulton MP (from
       22/2/10) | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator
     M Bishop | 
   Mr
     M Danby MP | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator M Cormann (till
     23/09/08) | 
   Ms
     A Ellis MP | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator A Eggleston (till
     19/03/08) | 
   The
     Hon J Fitzgibbon MP (from
       15/06/09) | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator
     the Hon A Ferguson  
     (from 01/07/08)  | 
   Mr S W Gibbons MP  | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator
     M Fifield | 
   Ms S Grierson MP | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator
     M Furner (from
       16/03/09) | 
   Mr
     D Hale MP | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator S Hanson-Young 
     (from 04/12/08)  | 
   The
     Hon I Macfarlane MP (till
       3/02/10) | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator
     the Hon D Johnston 
     (from 23/09/08)  | 
   Mrs L Markus MP (from 25/09/08) | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator L J Kirk (till 30/06/08) | 
   Ms
     S Mirabella MP(till
       11/03/09) | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator S Ludlam (from 26/11/08) | 
   The
     Hon J Murphy MP (from
       20/03/09) | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator
     the Hon J A L (Sandy) Macdonald (till 30/06/08) | 
   Mr
     R Oakeshott MP (from
       20/03/09) | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator C M Moore  | 
   Ms
     M Parke MP | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator K O’Brien (from
     01/07/08) | 
   Ms
     K Rea MP | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator M Payne (from 19/03/08) | 
   Mr B Ripoll MP | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator N Stott Despoja (till
     30/06/08) | 
   The
     Hon A Robb AO MP (till
       25/09/08) | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator R Trood | 
   Mr S Robert MP | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator R S Webber (till 30/06/08) | 
   The
     Hon P Ruddock MP | 
 
 
   |   | 
   The
     Hon B Baldwin MP | 
   Ms
     J Saffin MP | 
 
 
   |   | 
   The
     Hon A Bevis MP | 
   The
     Hon B Scott MP | 
 
 
   |   | 
     | 
   Mr
     W Truss (from
       3/02/10 till 22/2/10) | 
 
 
   |   | 
     | 
   Ms
     M Vamvakinou MP | 
 
 
   | Secretary | 
   Dr M Kerley | 
     | 
 
 
Membership of the Defence Sub-Committee
 
  | 
   Chair 
   | 
  
   The Hon A Bevis  MP 
   | 
  
     
   | 
 
 
  | 
   Deputy
  Chair 
   | 
  
   The Hon B Baldwin MP 
   | 
  
     
   | 
 
 
  | 
   Members 
   | 
  
   Senator
  M Bishop 
 
   | 
  
   Mr
  M Danby MP 
  
   | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator
     the Hon A Ferguson  | 
   The
     Hon J Fitzgibbon MP  | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator M Fifield  | 
   Mr
     S W Gibbons MP | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator M Forshaw (ex officio) | 
   Ms S Grierson MP | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator
     M Furner  | 
   Mr
     D Hale MP | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator
     the Hon D Johnston | 
   The
     Hon D Hawker MP (ex officio) | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator S Ludlum  | 
   Mrs
     L Markus MP | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator
     K O’Brien   | 
   Mr
     R Oakeshott MP | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator
     M Payne   | 
   Mr
     S Robert MP | 
 
 
   |   | 
   Senator
     R Trood | 
   Ms
     J Saffin MP | 
 
 
   |   | 
     | 
   The
  Hon B Scott MP   | 
 
Committee Secretariat
 
  | 
   Secretary 
   | 
  
   Dr Margot Kerley 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   Inquiry
  Secretaries 
   | 
  
   Mr Paul Zinkel 
 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   | 
  
   Mr Robert Little 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   Defence
  Adviser 
   | 
  
   CMDR Clive Dunchue 
   | 
 
 
   | 
      Office
  Manager 
      | 
   
      Mrs Donna Quintus-Bosz 
      | 
 
 
   Administrative
     Officer  | 
   Ms Gillian Drew  | 
 
 
      | 
   Ms Sonya Gaspar  | 
 
 
Terms of reference
Pursuant to paragraph 1 (b) of its resolution of appointment,
the Joint Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade is empowered
to consider and report on the annual reports of government agencies, in
accordance with a schedule presented by the Speaker of the House of
Representatives.[1]
The Speaker’s schedule lists annual reports from agencies
within the Defence and Foreign Affairs portfolios as being available for review
by the Committee.[2]
List of abbreviations
 
  | 
   AEW&C 
   | 
  
   Airborne Early Warning and Control 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   CBR 
   | 
  
   centre barrel replacement 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   ADF 
   | 
  
   Australian Defence Force 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   ANA 
   | 
  
   Afghan National Army 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   ANAO 
   | 
  
   Australian National Audit Office 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   ANEF 
   | 
  
   Australian Noise Exposure
  Forecast 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   ANP 
   | 
  
   Afghan National Police 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   ARH 
   | 
  
   Armed Reconnaissance Helicopter 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   AWD 
   | 
  
   Air Warfare Destroyers 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   CDF 
   | 
  
   Chief of the Defence Force 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   CDG 
   | 
  
   Capability Development Group 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   CEO 
   | 
  
   Chief Executive Officer 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   CFO 
   | 
  
   Chief Financial Officer 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   CT 
   | 
  
   Counterterrorism 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   CTOL 
   | 
  
   Conventional take-off and landing 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   DDG 51 
   | 
  
   US Arleigh Burke class guided
  missile destroyers 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   DCP 
   | 
  
   Defence Capability Plan 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   DMO 
   | 
  
   Defence Materiel Organisation 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   DNV 
   | 
  
   Det Norske Veritas 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   DSTO 
   | 
  
   Defence Science and Technology
  Organisation 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   EADS 
   | 
  
   European Aeronautic Defence and
  Space 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   EMD 
   | 
  
   Engineering, manufacturing and
  development 
 
   | 
 
 
   | 
      FCA 
      | 
   
      Federal Court of Australia 
      | 
 
 
   F-FDTL  | 
   Falintil-Forças de Defesa de
     Timor Leste  | 
 
 
   FFG  | 
   Guided Missile Frigates  | 
 
 
   FMA Act  | 
   Financial Management and
     Accountability Act 1997  | 
 
 
   FOC  | 
   Final Operational Capability  | 
 
 
   GAO  | 
   US Government Accounting Office  | 
 
 
   GIRoA  | 
   Government of the Islamic Republic
     of Afghanistan  | 
 
 
   HF  | 
   High Frequency  | 
 
 
   HMAS  | 
   Her Majesty’s Australian Ships  | 
 
 
   IED  | 
   Improvised explosive devices  | 
 
 
   IOC  | 
   Initial Operational Capability  | 
 
 
   ISAF  | 
   International Security Assistance
     Force  | 
 
 
   ISF  | 
   International Stabilisation Force  | 
 
 
   JLTV  | 
   Joint Light Tactical Vehicle  | 
 
 
   JSF  | 
   Joint Strike Fighter  | 
 
 
   L-3  | 
   L‑3 Communications MAS Inc  | 
 
 
   LARS  | 
   Launch and Recovery System  | 
 
 
   LHD  | 
   Landing helicopter deck  | 
 
 
   MOT  | 
   Military-Off-The-Shelf  | 
 
 
   MRH  | 
   Multi Role Helicopter  | 
 
 
   MSA  | 
   Manufactured and supported in
     Australia  | 
 
 
   NACC  | 
   New Air Combat Capability  | 
 
 
   NATO  | 
   North Atlantic Treaty
     Organization  | 
 
 
   NFH  | 
   Nato Frigate Helicopter  | 
 
 
   NZDF  | 
   New Zealand Defence Force  | 
 
 
   PBS  | 
   Portfolio Budget Statement  | 
 
 
   PER  | 
   Public Environment Report  | 
 
 
   PMV-L  | 
   Protected Mobility Vehicles - light  | 
 
 
   PS Act  | 
   Public Service Act 1999  | 
 
 
   RAAF  | 
   Royal Australian Air Force  | 
 
 
   SAS  | 
   Special Air Service  | 
 
 
   SES  | 
   Senior Executive Service  | 
 
 
   SETF  | 
   Submarine Escape Training
     Facility  | 
 
 
   TUCF  | 
   The Underwater Centre Fremantle  | 
 
 
   UN  | 
   United Nations  | 
 
 
   UNMIT  | 
   United Nations Integrated Mission
     in Timor-Leste  | 
 
 
   UNSCR  | 
   United Nations Security Council
     resolution  | 
 
 
   US  | 
   United States  | 
 
 
   USAF  | 
   United States Air Force  | 
 
 
   USN  | 
   United States Navy  | 
 
 
 
 
                    Navigation: Contents | Next Page
                
                    
                
Back to top