Chapter 1 Introduction
The Shareholder Minister’s Second Report on the rollout of the National
Broadband Network (NBN) details performance information relating to progress of
the NBN rollout for the period ended on 31 December 2011.
Since receiving the previous performance report, construction of the NBN
is entering into its next phase and progressing to rollout in second release
sites across Australia.
In addition, the Regional Backbone Blackspots Program which has
established new transmission links to regional centres was completed in
Regulatory matters have progressed, with the Australian Competition and
Consumer Commission (ACCC) approval of Telstra’s Structural Separation
Undertaking (SSU) and draft (customer) migration plan. This process has enabled
the Binding Definitive Agreement between the NBN Co and Telstra (the
Telstra Agreement) to come into force. In turn, the Telstra Agreement will
allow for existing Telstra telecommunications infrastructure to be used for the
NBN rollout and Telstra customers to be migrated to the NBN.
The Binding Definitive Agreement between the NBN Co and Singtel Optus
(the Optus Agreement), has also received ACCC approval. The Optus Agreement,
similarly to the Telstra Agreement will enable decommissioning of the Optus Hybrid
Fibre Coaxial (HFC) network and migration of its customers to the NBN.
While the ACCC’s consideration of the NBN Co’s Special Access
Undertaking (SAU) is yet to be completed, 40 Retail Service Providers (RSPs)
have signed a 12-month Wholesale Broadband Agreement (WBA) with the NBN Co
and around 26 of these RSPs are offering internet services through the NBN.
Matters such as the timeframe for receiving the NBN, and requests for
the extension of the fibre footprint were raised during the previous review
period. These issues and associated community consultation, as well as the
adequacy of NBN rollout reporting remain topical for the Third Review.
Pursuant to its Resolution of Appointment (RoA) and in accordance with
its terms of reference, the committee is required to report to the Parliament
and the NBN Shareholder Ministers every six months ‘until
the NBN is complete and operational’.
The committee is primarily enabled to examine and report on matters
relating to the NBN Co’s objective to connect Australian premises to the NBN
n The achievement of
take-up targets as outlined in the NBN Co Corporate Plan.
n NBN Rollout
performance and matters relating to the NBN Co such as consumer engagement,
complaint handling, risk management.
n ‘Any other matter
pertaining to the NBN rollout that the committee considers relevant.’
As part of the review process, the committee has previously commented on
the type of performance information it would like to receive NBN rollout data
on. This includes key performance indicators that it considers would provide an
accurate ‘snap shot’ of NBN rollout progress.
The performance information provided in the Shareholder Ministers’
report forms the basis for the committee’s six-monthly review of the NBN
rollout. This information is further examined and supplemented by submissions,
published reports, hearings and questions placed on notice which are part of
the usual parliamentary committee inquiry process.
The Shareholder Ministers’ performance report provides an overview of
the NBN Co’s progress in managing the NBN rollout and covers the six month period
from 1 July to 31 December 2011, as well as an update on matters progressed
until 31 March 2012. As a result, he committee is able to follow and report on
matters that have been progressed and also on issues that are current and may
be deemed to require future action.
To date, the committee has reviewed and reported on a number of
significant and ongoing issues associated with the rollout of the NBN. These
n NBN rollout across
the three technologies of fibre, wireless and satellite
n issues raised and
faced by regional and remote areas
n regulatory issues
associated with establishment of the NBN
n e-readiness of
communities, governments and individuals and associated consultation by the NBN
The committee’s First Report was presented to the
Parliament to meet its 31 August 2011 reporting date and included discussion
about the role of the committee, the conduct of future reviews and an overview
of the NBN rollout program. The committee again reported to the Parliament on 24 November
2011 through its Second Report. The Second Report included additional comment
on issues raised in the First Report as well as introducing a number of new
areas of review.
By presenting its Second Report before the end of the first reporting
period, the committee adjusted its reporting timetable from the six month
period starting in August and ending in February (as provided for in its RoA)
to the period which commences in June and ends in December.
The change in reporting timetable was supported by the Shareholder
Ministers who agreed to provide a six-monthly report to the NBN rollout review
process no later than three months before the expected reporting date.
After initial delay, the committee received the Shareholder Minister’s
first six-monthly performance report on 23 September 2011. The performance
report included information relevant to the progress of the NBN rollout for the
six-month period ended on 30 June 2011. The Shareholder Minister’s second
report, received on 9 April 2012 provides similar information on the progress
of the NBN rollout and covers the six-month period ended on 31 December 2011.
During the Third Review period, the Government also formally responded
to the committee’s First and Second Reports.
About the Review
Objectives and Scope
As part of its Third Review of the six-monthly rollout of the NBN, the
committee examined and provided comment on the:
n NBN rollout, through
the fibre, wireless and satellite networks
Ministers’ six monthly performance report
n ongoing regulatory
and pricing matters
n e-readiness of small
and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs).
Through a working-group approach, the committee has also continued its
examination of the following:
n The potential of
private equity to fund the NBN; and
n Telstra workforce
issues associated with the Retraining Funding Deed under the Telstra Agreement.
In addition to these matters, the committee has continued to examine
issues raised during the First and Second Reviews and broader issues arising
from the NBN rollout. These issues include the regulatory framework
underpinning the NBN rollout, and the NBN rollout schedule in regard to
community expectations and consultation.
The review was announced and submissions called for through the issue of
media releases on 29 February and 5 March 2012 and an advertisement in The
Australian on 7 March 2012. Submissions were requested to be received by 5
Appendix A lists the 22 submissions and two exhibits received as part of
the committee’s Third Review.
The committee subsequently held two public hearings on 16 and
30 April 2012 in Sydney and Willunga, respectively. The
committee also conducted an inspection in Willunga on 30 April 2012.
Witnesses who gave evidence at public hearings are listed at Appendix B.
Transcripts of the public hearings are available at www.aph.gov.au/jcnbn.
On 30 April 2012, as part of its Third Review the committee conducted an
inspection of various NBN rollout sites in the first release location of Willunga.
The NBN infrastructure seen at the Willunga inspection expanded on similar
information received and infrastructure visited at the Broken Hill and Melbourne
inspections in relation to the committee’s Second Review.
As part of the inspection, the committee: viewed NBN street
infrastructure which forms part of the NBN fibre network. In addition, the
committee inspected the types of products and applications an NBN connection can
provide for research and learning by visiting the Community Library and Willunga
High School. The committee also visited a local business which is connected to
the NBN, viewed the premise connecting devices and discussed the business’
experience of the NBN.
The inspection is discussed in more detail in Chapter 5.
Chapter 2 examines the NBN rollout performance information and
associated issues. This includes discussion about the revision of targets and
key performance indicators contained in the NBN Co Corporate Plan, in the
context of the changed regulatory environment and the release of the 3-year NBN
Chapter 3 contains an overview of the regulatory and pricing issues
associated with the rollout of the NBN. Matters discussed include: the coming
into force of the Telstra and Optus Agreements, the ACCC review of the NBN Co
SAU and developments relating to the WBA. This chapter also includes discussion
about improving the e-readiness of SMEs.
Chapter 4 outlines the issues associated with the construction contracts
awarded by the NBN Co for First Release sites. More broadly, network security
considerations in awarding contracts and the possible impact on the NBN rollout
is also discussed.
Chapter 5 builds on the findings from the First and Second Reports in
regard to the advantages and challenges presented by the NBN rollout in regional
and remote areas of Australia.
Chapter 6 examines issues associated with private equity engagement in
funding the NBN. It also considers Telstra workforce issues associated with the
Retraining Funding Deed under the Telstra Agreement.