Parliamentary Library Vital Issues Seminar—Australia’s role and commitment in Afghanistan

Parliament house flag post

Parliamentary Library Vital Issues Seminar—Australia’s role and commitment in Afghanistan

Posted 25/10/2010 by Nicole Brangwin

Remnants of an Army by Elizabeth Butler depicting the arrival of assistant surgeon, William Brydon, at Jalalabad on 13 January 1842.
This seminar, held on 20 October 2010, featured distinguished speakers Major General Jim Molan AO DSC and Mr Geoffrey Barker who provided contrasting perspectives on Australia’s continued involvement in Afghanistan. The seminar was chaired by Senator Russell Trood.

Major General Jim Molan (Retd)

MAJGEN Molan presented a speech entitled ‘Flying in the face of history, graveyard of empires’. MAJGEN Molan commented that Afghanistan is arguably the most invaded and occupied nation on the planet and that contrary to popular belief not all of these invasions have failed! He noted, however, that the difference between previous conflicts and now is that the objective of the current war is not to occupy Afghanistan but to ‘give the Afghan people some breathing space’ to develop their own political systems.

MAJGEN Molan stated that the original reasons for our involvement in Afghanistan are no longer as important as what we can achieve and how we do it. He asserted that our self-interest is still served by removing one safe-haven for terrorist groups and promoting greater regional stability. He said the war will be won with good leadership, a good plan, and adequate resourcing. However, he also stated that it is the Afghan people who must ultimately win the conflict, not the coalition of nations that comprise the interventionist forces. MAJGEN Molan also highlighted what he believed to be the negative humanitarian and security ramifications of any premature withdrawal.

MAJGEN Molan addressed a number of issues that he believes tend to derail discussions about the war in Afghanistan. The ‘derailing questions’ and MAJGEN Molan’s responses to them were:
  • the notion that Afghanistan is the ‘graveyard of empires’—this is not so 
  • we should never try to impose Western values on the Afghan people—we are not 
  • there is no military solution—no one has ever claimed that there is 
  • there are too many military personnel and not enough civilians—without the military, the civilians would be killed 
  • we have been there for nine years and have not won—Afghanistan was a two year war extended by poor decision-making and is still capable of a positive outcome, and  
  • our military commanders are not asking for more resources—we might not need more resources for our current task of training and mentoring, but this task is insufficient for our overall mission to be a success.
The last dot point is the crucial one for MAJGEN Molan—Australia’s military role is too narrow and excludes the conduct of offensive activities other than by Australian Special Forces. He believes that coalition forces must reduce the Taliban threat or the Afghan National Army (ANA) will not survive once the coalition withdraws, but he argued that more troops and resources are needed to achieve this objective. He also argued that not enough is being done to protect the local population.

On the issue of Pakistan, MAJGEN Molan believes that Pakistan’s failure to fully cooperate does not mean that we will fail. He noted that the US Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Admiral Mike Mullen, recently stated that the Afghan/Pakistan border remains the ‘epicentre of terrorism’ and that we should expect a major offensive by Pakistan against terrorist safe-havens in the future. However, success in Afghanistan, MAJGEN Molan noted, does not hinge on Pakistan.

Geoffrey Barker

Mr Barker began by stating that he is a foreign and security policy realist of a ‘Machiavellian and Hobbesian disposition’. As he asserted in his article of 30 August in the Australian Financial Review, it is not clear why Australia is in Afghanistan and how we plan to leave. He believes that Afghanistan presents no threat to Australia’s security. His view is:
  • the war is unwinnable
  • the Afghan Government is irredeemably corrupt and incompetent 
  • the current approach of talking with the Taliban undermines the fight; it basically says that Karzai has ‘run up the white flag’ 
  • al Qaeda has gone on to establish themselves in other safe-havens such as Yemen, Somalia and Pakistan 
  • threats from terrorism are increasingly ‘home-grown’, and should we succeed in Afghanistan, many would still rebel, and 
  • we cannot destroy the Taliban or al Qaeda. On one similar point to MAJGEN Molan, Mr Barker argued that Pakistan is the real issue—we are fighting the wrong war in the wrong place.
Mr Barker pointed out that despite a substantial numerical advantage, the ISAF nations and the Afghan forces cannot seem to overwhelm the 13 000 strong Taliban force. He said that the Dutch, Canadians and the UK have already decided the war is unwinnable and are getting out. Many people argue that Australia’s major motivation for being in Afghanistan is to uphold the alliance with the United States. Mr Barker argued that Australia’s record in supporting the US in its wars has been impeccable but the US does not expect Australia to get involved in all of its wars. Other countries closely aligned with the US have not supported certain US wars and their relations with the US have not been damaged (for example, the UK refused to get involved in the Vietnam War).

He disagrees with the argument put by the former Chief of Army, Lieutenant General Peter Leahy, that priority should be given to increasing the civilian presence in Afghanistan. Mr Barker believes this would require an expanded military effort to ensure the protection of civilian staff.

He asked what a successful Afghan society should look like, and claimed that no one knows—but that we are unlikely to get a society that reflects ours.

For further details about the Parliamentary Library’s Vital Issues Seminars and Lectures, or to listen to this seminar in its entirety (including the question and answer session), go to the Parliamentary Library’s website.

(post co-authored by David Watt)

(Image: Elizabeth Butler, The Remnants of an Army, 1879, sourced from

Thank you for your comment. If it does not require moderation, it will appear shortly.
Facebook LinkedIn Twitter Add | Email Print


Flagpost is a blog on current issues of interest to members of the Australian Parliament

Parliamentary Library Logo showing Information Analysis & Advice




refugees asylum immigration Australian foreign policy Parliament climate change elections women social security Indigenous Australians Australian Bureau of Statistics Employment taxation Sport illicit drugs people trafficking Medicare welfare reform Australian Defence Force higher education welfare policy United Nations Asia income management Middle East criminal law disability Australian Sports Anti-Doping Agency World Anti-Doping Agency United States federal budget gambling school education forced labour aid statistics Australian Electoral Commission WADA health financing emissions trading Australia in the Asian Century steroids detention Private health insurance OECD ASADA labour force transport Law Enforcement Australian Federal Police Industrial Relations dental health National Disability Insurance Scheme slavery Senate election results Papua New Guinea Australian Public Service International Women's Day corruption Afghanistan Fair Work Act child protection people smuggling debt federal election 2013 parliamentary procedure poker machines ALP New Zealand Australian Crime Commission Newstart Parenting Payment 43rd Parliament political parties Census constitution High Court skilled migration voting Federal Court terrorist groups Higher Education Loan Program HECS youth paid parental leave Aviation environment foreign debt gross debt net debt defence capability customs doping health crime health risks multiculturalism aged care Gonski Review of Funding for Schooling sex slavery sea farers Special Rapporteur leadership United Kingdom UK Parliament Electoral reform politics banking firearms public policy violence against women domestic violence mental health China ADRV terrorism social media pensions welfare ASIO intelligence community Australian Security Intelligence Organisation governance public service reform Carbon Pricing Mechanism carbon tax mining military history employer employee fishing by-election European Union same sex relationships international relations coal seam gas family assistance planning United Nations Security Council Australian economy food vocational education and training Drugs Indonesia children codes of conduct terrorist financing Productivity asylum seekers early childhood education Canada Population Financial sector national security fuel disability employment Tasmania integrity science research and development Australian Secret Intelligence Service sexual abuse federal state relations World Trade Organization Australia accountability housing affordability bulk billing water renewable energy children's health health policy Governor-General US economy export liquefied natural gas foreign bribery question time speaker superannuation expertise Senators and Members climate Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change Department of Agriculture Fisheries and Forestry food labelling Pacific Islands reserved seats new psychoactive substances synthetic drugs UNODC carbon markets health reform Indigenous constitutional recognition of local government local government consumer laws PISA royal commission US politics language education baby bonus Leaders of the Opposition Parliamentary remuneration health system Australia Greens money laundering servitude Trafficking Protocol energy forced marriage rural and regional Northern Territory Emergency Response ministries social citizenship human rights housing Speaker; House of Representatives; Parliament citizenship Defence High Court; Indigenous; Indigenous Australians; Native Title ACT Indigenous education Norfolk Island External Territories emissions reduction fund; climate change child care funding refugees immigration asylum procurement Indigenous health e-voting internet voting nsw state elections 44th Parliament 2015 ABS Age Pension Death penalty capital punishment execution Bali nine Bali bombings Trade EU China soft power education Fiji India Disability Support Pension Antarctica Diplomacy by-elections state and territories workers Bills anti-corruption fraud bribery transparency corporate ownership whistleblower G20 economic reform innovation standards NATO Members of Parliament Scottish referendum Middle East; national security; terrorism social services Criminal Code Amendment (Misrepresentation of Age to a Minor) Bill 2013 online grooming sexual assault of minors ACT Assembly public health smoking plain packaging tobacco cigarettes Asia; Japan; international relations Work Health and Safety Migration; asylum seekers; regional processing China; United States; international relations fiscal policy Racial Discrimination Act; social policy; human rights; indigenous Australians Foreign policy Southeast Asia Israel Palestine regional unemployment asylum refugees immigration political finance donations foreign aid Economics efficiency human rights; Racial Discrimination Act employment law bullying Animal law; food copyright Australian Law Reform Commission industry peace keeping contracts workplace policies trade unions same-sex marriage disorderly conduct retirement Parliament House standing orders public housing prime ministers election timetable sitting days First speech defence budget submarines Somalia GDP forestry world heritage political engagement leave loading Trade; tariffs; safeguards; Anti-dumping public interest disclosure whistleblowing Productivity Commission regulation limitation period universities Ireland cancer gene patents genetic testing suspension of standing and sessional orders animal health live exports welfare systems infant mortality middle class welfare honorary citizen railways disciplinary tribunals standard of proof World Health Organisation arts international students skilled graduate visas temporary employment visas apologies roads Italy national heritage NHMRC nutrition anti-dumping Constitutional reform referendum Rent Assistance competition policy pharmaceutical benefits scheme obesity evidence law sacrament of confession US presidential election international days DFAT UN General Assembly deregulation Regulation Impact Statements administrative law small business Breaker Morant homelessness regional engagement social determinants of health abortion Youth Allowance Members suspension citizen engagement policymaking federal election 2010 workplace health and safety Trafficking in Persons Report marine reserves hearing TAFE Victoria astronomy resources sector YMCA youth parliament alcohol Korea rebate Australian Greens presidential nomination Racial Discrimination Act entitlements political parties preselection solar hot water Financial Action Taskforce Horn of Africa peacekeeping piracy Great Barrier Reef Stronger futures political financing Hung Parliament political education social inclusion Social Inclusion Board maritime early childhood National Quality Framework for Early Childhood Education and Care Murray-Darling Basin Iran sanctions Norway

Show all
Show less
Back to top