From: Geoff Thompson [tce@thompson-consulting.com.au]
Sent: Thursday, 27 June 2002 6:52 AM
To: ecita.sen@aph.gov.au
Subject: Telstra ADSL Inquiry
The Chairman
Senate Inquiry into Telstra ADSL
 
I am writing to the Senate inquiry after becoming totally frustrated with my attempts to obtain an ADSL broadband connection for use by my consulting engineering practice.  We operate from an office attached to my home at Prince Henry Heights, which is only about 5 minutes travel from the centre of Toowoomba.
 
We have three telephone lines into the premises, two business and one private.  We also operate two CDMA phones and a digital phone.  All of these services plus our internet access are with Telstra - in fact I have never dealt with anyone else because I believed that Telstra were there to look after the whole of the country, not just to pick the eyes out of the more lucrative city markets.
 
Of late I have been finding that the cost of our internet access has been increasing, principally due to call drop-outs, as we are on a fixed monthly plan with BigPond.  I have made several attempts to be connected to the ADSL broadband service because I believe that it would be an ideal and cost effective method of accessing the internet.  We have large drawing files and specification documents to upload and download to and from our off site sub-consultants.
 
Several months ago I was told on application to Telstra for ADSL that, "No, we can't provide that service yet, but it is coming."  Over the last few weeks there has been a concerted advertising effort by Telstra extolling the virtues of broadband connection, complete with images of a speeding train.  This convinced me to try again.
 
On 5 June I rang the 1800 151 311 number as per the advertisement in the Courier Mail to obtain my "faster affordable internet experience", only to be told that, despite my close proximity to the centre of a large regional centre like Toowoomba, I was unable to obtain an ADSL connection because we have "a pair gain phone line system", and, "You can't expect to just ring up and get that sort of service like you would a telephone."  Of course, for a lot more money I could get a two-way satellite link - "faster" of course, but hardly falling into the category of "affordable".  I believe that the current round of BigPond broadband advertisements must almost be verging on false and misleading advertising.
 
I made contact with the electorate office of my local member of parliament and dealt with a very helpful aide who made contact with the local Telstra Countrywide office.  One of the Countrywide staff then rang me back to correct some of the mis-information that I had been given during my previous telephone contact with Telstra.  It appears that we have standard telephone lines, but are unable to access ADSL because we have a line length of 4800 metres, and the service will only reliably work up to a line length of 4000 metres from the telephone exchange.
 
What sort of second class service is the government accepting from Telstra on our behalf?  If this is the level of service offered in Toowoomba, a headquarters for Telstra Countrywide, what service are people getting further out?  We need to be able to have very similar, if not the same, level of internet access available in the country as in the capital cities.  This also needs to be at a similar cost if we are to be competitive with our city cousins.  It seems incredible that Telstra are spending such huge sums of money advertising this product when it has such a restrictive physical constraint.  I believe that the advertising is more for the politicians' benefit, so that you can see how readily available this service is, rather than for the consumers' benefit. 

Regards
 
Geoff Thompson
Director
 
Thompson Consulting Engineers Pty Ltd
e-mail tce@thompson-consulting.com.au
web page http://www.thompson-consulting.com.au
Phone +61 7 4638 5780    Fax +61 7 4638 5790
Mobile 0429 119 709
 
Postal Address
PO Box 2184, Toowoomba QLD 4350