Skip to section navigationSkip to content Commonwealth of Australia Coat of Arms Parliament of Australia - Department of the Parliamentary Library
HomeSenateHouse of RepresentativesLive BroadcastingThis Week in Parliament FindFrequently asked questionsContact

Research Note 8 1996-97

International Airline Travel and Consumer Issues

Matthew James
Science, Technology, Environment and Resources Group


The Global Trip

Have you booked your seat for your next round-the-world sojourn? Are you taking advantage of one of the many multiple airline linkups that provide one ticketing process for all of the international sectors? Do you expect to gain considerable frequent flyer points as a result of your travel?

Well, think again if you expect to have a hassle-free trip round-the-world. Even with a seat reservation and reconfirmation, do not expect a guaranteed flight! Nor may you receive all the frequent flyer points that you expect. Special menu requests do not always appear either. These realities of modern travel confront the unsuspecting traveller.

Despite the glowing hype of travel brochures, it pays to read the small print on the back page. However, even the contingencies and items listed there do not always account for all possible events. In reality, there are some major pitfalls facing Australian citizens when they journey around the globe by airlines, as there is no government or industry limit on overbooking.

Overbooking

Many of us would think that travel on airlines, after advance payment and confirmation, would be simple. However, airlines do not guarantee travel. A reservation is made when an airline records a request for a seat in its computer system. Once a passenger obtains a validated ticket that reflects reservations for a specific flight and date, the system confirms a possible seat.

However, seats assigned in advance are not guaranteed and form no part of the contract of carriage. To offset the lost revenue, most airlines overbook flights based on an analysis of the flight's historical 'no show' factor. Airlines recognise that overbooking of flights is not an ideal solution to the 'no show' problem that occurs when passengers fail to arrive for their flights. So even with a valid ticket and reservation, passengers may not even get on the plane (Choice 1995, 32-33)!

When more passengers than expected show up, staff solicit volunteers to give up their seats. If an insufficient number of passengers volunteer to take later flights, staff may deny boarding to those passengers who did not check in early. If airlines are unable to get passengers to their destinations, within two hours of their scheduled arrival time, the travellers may be eligible for denied boarding compensation. However, Australian domestic airlines do not provide such compensation.

Typically, staff select volunteers on a first-come, first-served basis, but before staff make the final decision, they must consider a number of aspects including the availability of later flights. They must work quickly to prevent a delayed departure and may inadvertently create duplicate lists of volunteers. Airlines will determine the compensation for volunteers be it monetary or travel credit. As an example, USAir, in partnership with Qantas and British Airways, will pay compensation for involuntary denied boarding to the amount of 200% of the sum of the values of the passenger's remaining flight coupons, up to US$400 (USAir 1993). This amount reduces if USAir arranges for comparable transport not arriving later than two hours after the planned arrival, or free or upgraded transport.

Frequent Flying

Qantas, Ansett and Air New Zealand spend much effort in promoting the continuity of their international airline frequent flyer reward programs. However, consumers really have to make an effort to ensure that airlines register the new points resulting from travel activities.

Passengers cannot always earn or use frequent flyer points on some partner airlines, as restrictions apply. Even if they do not, it may be up to the passenger to apply to the Australian airline in order to have accrued points added to the tally. Australian international airlines do not automatically add to passenger points for flights made on foreign airline partners. How many customers realise this?

Reward flights are often not available during peak periods of travel or to certain destinations. It can take frequent flyer members some perseverance to have airlines register their points and provide free travel. Ticket issuance itself may be a problem due to mail delays requiring fresh ticketing at the airport. Special promotions, offering extra points during certain periods, require diligence by consumers, as the points involved do not necessarily appear on passenger point statements, unless consumers query it.

Special Requests

Passenger requests for special meals, seats, assistance or other matters do not always translate readily from one airline to the next. Round-the-world travellers should be particularly aware of the need to reconfirm all such details well in advance of flight departures. Even this does not always work!

This raises matters of consumer rights on round-the-world tickets particularly. If complaining to an airline results in no effect, then to whom can the consumer turn while overseas? As pointed out earlier, there are few guarantees involved in these airline code sharing deals.

Future developments may include joint round-the-world fares having extended features and options. In all of this though, the needs of the traveller should remain paramount. Currently, Australian customers purchasing round-the-world tickets expect to receive service commensurate with that found on the issuing airline.


Global Alliances

Qantas Airways, British Airways and prospective partner American Airlines expect to form a core of a global World Alliance to collectively advertise and promote their services. While each may retain its own identity, they may use a common sub-brand for the alliance in a similar way to the KLM Royal Dutch Airlines and Northwest Airlines alliance. Such code sharing linkages also provide for significant operational savings to transfers, ticketing, frequent flyer schemes and the like, making them of appeal to airlines. Ansett has links with other airlines including United Airlines. The latter now links to Lufthansa, SAS, Thai Airways and Air Canada. Singapore Airlines now links with Delta Airlines and Swissair. Deregulation has made the airline industry more competitive, but these links keep control in few hands (BTCE 1996, 14-20).

References

BTCE 1996, 'Code Sharing in International Aviation: A Discussion Paper', Working Paper 21, February.

Choice 1995, 'Overbooking Ordeals', December, p.32-3.

USAir 1993, Terms of Transportation, March, (pamphlet).

 

top