Skip to section navigationSkip to content Commonwealth of Australia Coat of Arms Parliament of Australia - Department of the Parliamentary Library
HomeSenateHouse of RepresentativesLive BroadcastingThis Week in Parliament FindFrequently asked questionsContact


Swiss emissions trading scheme

Overall Swiss policy

TARGETS
Switzerland has ratified the Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. Its target for reductions of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions between 2008 and 2012 is 8 per cent less than its emissions levels in 1990. This works out to be about 48.25 million tonnes of carbon dioxide (CO2) equivalent emissions per year throughout this period.

EMISSIONS TRADING
Briefly, the Swiss emissions trading scheme enables scheme participants to avoid the CO2 tax. These measures are discussed in greater detail below.

LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND OPERATION
The principles and instruments of Swiss environmental policy are formulated in the Federal Act on the Protection of the Environment, adopted in 1985 and revised in 1995 and 2003. This Act has been supplemented by the Federal Act on the Reduction of CO2 Emissions (CO2 Act), which was adopted in 1999. These two laws provide the basis for the Swiss national climate change policy.

Both pieces of legislation have a direct bearing on compliance with commitments under the Kyoto Protocol. The CO2 Act covers about 75 per cent of Switzerland’s GHG emissions. The Environmental Protection Act provides for measures to mitigate emissions from waste disposal (methane) synthetic gases.

FEDERAL ACT ON THE REDUCTION OF CO2 EMISSIONS
The CO2 Act establishes a broad framework for measures designed to reduce CO2 emissions and is the core element of Swiss climate policy. It covers energy-related CO2 emissions and provides the principal legal basis for compliance with Switzerland's Kyoto commitments. The CO2 Act stipulates an overall reduction target of 10 per cent by 2010 compared to 1990 levels. Apart from this overall reduction target, emissions from heating/process fuels are to be lowered by 15 per cent and emissions from transport fuels by 8 per cent.

In the first stage of implementation of the CO2 Act, priority was to be given to voluntary action to lower fossil fuel consumption. However, as periodically updated energy projections indicated in 2004 that voluntary and other CO2-related measures would not be sufficient to meet the reduction target in 2010, the Swiss Federal Council was authorized to resort to an incentive tax.

The tax rates depend on the shortfalls in meeting the sectoral targets and require the approval of Parliament. Net revenues are to be fully redistributed to the population on a per-capita basis and to businesses as a percentage of wages paid. Exemption from the tax will be granted to energy-intensive and high emitting industries which have entered into legally binding CO2 reduction commitments.

The CO2 Act also allows for the use of Kyoto Protocol flexible mechanisms supplemental to domestic action. An ordinance relating to the requirements for Clean Development and Joint Implementation mechanisms (CDM/JI) projects, certificates and supplementarily was adopted by the Federal Council in June 2005, and the National Registry has implemented and operational it by mid 2006.

Having assessed several options, the Swiss Federal Council decided on 23 March 2005 to introduce a CO2 tax from 1 January 2008, to request Parliament's approval of a tax rate of SFr12 per tonne of CO2 on heating/process fuels. The rate varies according to how emissions rise or fall against an emissions baseline figure. This baseline figure is reset annually.

Emissions Trading
As noted above, he main policy instrument in Switzerland is the CO2 tax. However, a company may avoid paying the tax by undertaking a legally binding commitment to reduce its GHG emissions by a set amount during the period 2008–2012.

PERMIT ALLOCATION
Permits are issued free of charge. Reduction targets in absolute terms are to be calculated using a "bottom-up" approach—a company's potential to reduce emissions, from a technical and economic viewpoint, is assessed on the basis of projected production and emissions, taking into account any CO2 reduction measures already implemented. A simplified approach is used for small and medium enterprises (SMEs).
Each company which has been exempted of the CO2 tax by an official decision receives emission allowances or permits corresponding exactly to its reduction target. If the company cuts its CO2 emissions below this target, it can sell the surplus allowances. If it emits CO2 in excess of its target, it can buy allowances from other companies.

OPERATION AND FOREIGN EMISSIONS CREDITS
Starting in 2008, emission allowances equivalent to the amount of CO2 emitted have to be surrendered each year. To cover excess emissions, allowances have to be purchased on the domestic or international markets and/or earned through emission reduction projects abroad (that is the CDM/JI projects noted above). As a rule, foreign certificates may be used to cover a maximum of 8 per cent of a particular company's target.

SMALL COMPANIES
Small companies that participate in the Swiss scheme have no specific reduction targets. But participating small companies have either a specific target value for their emissions (benchmark model) or a plan of actions (SME model) to reduce their emissions. Such participating companies do not receive any emission allowances. However, they can buy emission credits to fulfil their commitments.

PENALTIES
In the event of non-compliance, the CO2 tax is to be paid retroactively for each tonne of CO2 emitted since exemption was granted.

LINKING TO THE EU ETS
The Swiss government intends to link this emissions trading scheme to the European Union's emissions trading scheme (EU ETS). To date, no time frame for this development has been set.

While the Swiss emissions trading scheme is technically compatible with the EU ETS there are two major obstacles to overcome:

  • Linking the Swiss scheme and the EU ETS would require a negotiated treaty, which will take some time to finalise.

  • There is a substantial difference in penalties imposed on companies that do not comply with their obligations. With the Swiss scheme the penalty ranges from SFr 12 to 36 per tonne of CO2 emitted but with the EU ETS this penalty is €100 per tonne of CO2 emitted above a certain level.

Further reading:

Véronique Stein, Department of Geography, University of Geneva, 'Swiss policies and measures related to CO2 emissions reduction' at http://www.lcube.eu.com/pdf/athens/VSWG2swisslawsand%20measures.pdf.

Swiss Department of Environment, Transport, Energy and Communications, Federal Office for the Environment, 'Emissions Trading in Switzerland' at http://www.bafu.admin.ch/emissionshandel/05538/05540/index.html?lang=en.

Samuel Indermuhel, KPMG, 'European Emissions Trading Scheme enters Phase II—Switzerland strays off course for reductions', at http://www.kpmg.ch/docs/20080508_EU_Emissions_Trading_Scheme_enters_phase_II.pdf.



29 April, 2009 Comments to: web.library@aph.gov.au
Last reviewed 29 April, 2009 by the Parliamentary Library Web Manager
© Commonwealth of Australia
Parliament of Australia Web Site Privacy Statement
Images courtesy of AUSPIC
DNR08