Bills Digest no. 44, 2007-08 - Indigenous Education (Targeted Assistance) Amendment (Cape York Measures) Bill 2007

Indigenous Education (Targeted Assistance) Amendment (Cape York Measures) Bill 2007

Date introduced: 16 August 2007

House: House of Representatives

Portfolio: Education, Science and Training

Commencement: Royal Assent

Links: The relevant links to the Bill, Explanatory Memorandum and second reading speech can be accessed via BillsNet, which is at http://www.aph.gov.au/bills/. When Bills have been passed they can be found at ComLaw, which is at http://www.comlaw.gov.au/.

Inquiry by the Senate Employment, Workplace Relations and Education Committee (report to be presented on 10 September 2007).

Purpose

The Bill will appropriate additional funding under the Indigenous Education (Targeted Assistance) Act 2000 (the Act) to support the expansion of the Making Up for Lost Time in Literacy (MULTILIT) teaching methodology and the establishment of Student Education Trusts for Indigenous students in the communities of Coen, Hope Vale, Aurukun and Mossman Gorge in the Cape York region of Queensland.

The Department of Education, Science and Training (DEST) has estimated that

Background

This Indigenous education measure is part of a broader welfare reform trial in Cape York, announced in July 2007 by the Minister for Families, Community Services and Indigenous Affairs, the Hon. Mal Brough. The Minister committed $48 million to fund welfare reform trials in Hope Vale, Aurukun, Mossman Gorge and Coen. The trials aim to promote engagement in the real economy, reduce passive welfare and rebuild social norms, particularly as they affect the welfare of children and will begin at the start of the 2008 school year, subject to the support of the communities and the passage of legislation by the Queensland Government. [2]

The recommendations to achieve these aims were provided to the Australian and Queensland Governments by the Cape York Institute for Policy and Leadership (the Institute) in their report From Hand Out to Hand Up: Design Recommendations released in June 2007. Recommendations in the report covered four areas:

The Institute believes the education measures funded by the Bill will have a decisive impact on educational problems and will support engagement in the real economy: Clearly individuals will struggle to enter into the real economy unless they have mastered the basics. Mastering the basics is not happening in Cape York communities today . [4]

Making Up for Lost Time in Literacy (MULTILIT)

MULTILIT is a remedial reading program developed by Professor Kevin Wheldall and Dr Robyn Beaman of the Macquarie University Special Education Centre (MUSEC). It is a program specifically designed for low-progress readers in Year 2 and above who are reading at a level considerably below (typically two or more years below) that expected for their age. [5]

The Institute estimates that up to 70 per cent of Indigenous primary school students in Cape York need immediate remedial literacy instruction. In some schools, as few as 21 per cent of Indigenous students achieve minimum accepted levels in national literacy benchmark tests for years 3, 5 and 7.

In 2006 MULTILIT was trialled in Coen State School. At the beginning of the trial students were on average 3 years behind expected benchmarks in reading accuracy and 3 years behind in reading comprehension. A tutorial centre was established at the school and two MULTILIT instructors flown in for six months at a time to deliver the program to two groups of 10 students in Years 4 to 7. After 17 to 18 weeks of instruction, students gained, on average, 21.4 months in reading accuracy, a 19-month increase in word recognition and a 10.7 month increase in reading comprehension, after only one year. They could also correctly read 75 per cent more words per minute. [6]

The Director of the Institute, Noel Pearson, believes that the long-term strategic policies that aim to improve community life and reform the regular delivery of education by the state education departments will not help the students who are enrolled in Cape York Peninsula schools this year . [7] Some of these remedial strategies have been evaluated by the Institute as having merit but MULTILIT stands out as an evidence-based, remedial program, able to be implemented on a large scale quickly and with a track record of results. [8]

There are approximately 570 Indigenous students enrolled in schools in the four communities. It is anticipated that all will be involved in a MULTILIT intervention in some way over the four years. The funding in the Bill will assist in the establishment of a MULTILIT Tutorial Centre within the four communities; embed MULTILIT instructional practices across each school; provide for after-school community reading clubs; and provide support to transition-to-school programs in terms of pre-reading and language development in feeder pre-schools. [9]

Student Education Trusts (SETs)

SETs are voluntary education trusts that enable low-income parents and guardians or extended family members to save for their child s ongoing education costs. These costs can include school fees, uniforms, textbooks and excursion fees, as well as home-based expenses such as reading books, a computer and other learning aids. SETs have been designed by the Institute, but they are similar to other educational-savings funds, such as the Australian Scholarships Group, that are used throughout Australia.

The Institute will work with those families who wish to establish a SET to create and manage a trust account. Family members are then able to make regular contributions to their child s SET which can only be used to meet a child s education-related expenses. Families with SETs will also have access to education products and financial advice on education, in addition to money-management assistance.

A trial of SETs was conducted in Coen in 2005 with the result that there are currently 102 SETs for Coen children, which equates to approximately 90% of children under the age of 18 in the community, with up to two donors contributing an average of $30 40 per child per fortnight. [10]

The Institute envisages that parents will come to the Institute for advice and assistance with establishing a SET for their child. Consultants will help the donors work out their fortnightly contribution, ensure all forms are completed and submitted, answer questions, and talk donors through the process and benefits of establishing a SET for their child.

The trust guidelines would stipulate that funds be used for legitimate education purposes only. Parents are provided with regular financial statements showing the current balance and recent transactions. All costs associated with the trusts, such as monthly fees, auditing and administration costs, would be borne by the program. [11]

Financial implications

The Bill will appropriate an additional $2 million over the 2008 09 year under section 14A of the Act.

The Government has also approved additional funding of $8.1 million for these measures beyond 2008, which will be appropriated when the Act is amended for the provision of the 2009 12 quadrennium funding. [12]

Main provisions

Schedule 1 amends Item 4 in section 14A of the Act to reflect the increased appropriation.

Conclusion

The measures funded in the Bill meet the Government s stated priorities for Indigenous education of improving outcomes and school retention through shifting the resourcing to where it is most needed and targeting the resources into things that we know actually work . [13] The Bill implements broader Indigenous Affairs policy which is focussed on helping Indigenous families and individuals to become self-sufficient through strategies to encourage shared responsibility, harnessing the mainstream and engaging in the real economy. [14]

Noel Pearson and the Institute have stressed the need for a quick and efficient response to what they describe as an emergency: that a large proportion, perhaps a majority, of indigenous children attending primary school in Cape York Peninsula are destined to be excluded from mainstream society because they will be illiterate or semi-literate. [15] The Government is responding to the need for intervention, but unlike the emergency response in the Northern Territory this is a more measured response based on the evidence from trials, community consultations and partnerships. The SETs measure stresses working with families and encouraging them to plan and contribute to their children s schooling and development needs, rather than the imposition of an Income Management Regime and the quarantining of welfare payments which will be the experience of parents in the Northern Territory under the emergency intervention legislation. [16]

Endnotes