Fair Work Commission clarifies when an employer can direct an employee to attend a medical examination

Parliament house flag post

Fair Work Commission clarifies when an employer can direct an employee to attend a medical examination

Posted 7/07/2014 by Jaan Murphy


The Full Bench of the Fair Work Commission (FWC) recently handed down a judgment which examined the lawfulness of dismissing an employee who refused to attend a medical appointment, as directed by their employer.

Background

The Appellant (Mr Grant), worked as a boilermaker at a coal mine operated by the Respondent (BHP Coal). Around October 2011 the Appellant was injured at work, and was subsequently on sick leave from July 2012, prior to undergoing surgery in September 2012.

In March 2013 the Appellant provided the Respondent with generalised medical certificates signed by a medical practitioner who the Appellant had regularly seen over the course of his injury, stating he was ‘fit to return to his normal duties as and from Monday April 1st 2013’, and from the surgeon, stating he could return to full duties from 30 May 2013.

The Respondent was not (on the basis of the generalised medical certificates) satisfied that the Appellant could safely resume his pre-injury duties following an eight month long absence, during which the Appellant had undergone surgery, and directed the Appellant to attend its nominated medical specialist before being assigned duties.

The authority which allowed the Respondent to direct the Appellant to attend a specific medical practitioner was contested.

The Respondent said it was acting under the Coal Mining Safety and Health Act 1999 (Qld) (CMSH Act), whilst the Appellant argued that the relevant Enterprise Agreement (agreement) only required a medical certificate from an employee's medical practitioner prior to returning to work. The Respondent stated its obligations under the CMSH Act overrode any term in the agreement.

The Appellant failed to attend scheduled medical appointments and, following other events related to that failure, including attending the mine (despite having been directed not to do so), seeking to record conversations with other employees  and failing to participate in related investigations, was dismissed in May 2013.

The Appellant unsuccessfully brought an unfair dismissal case against the Respondent, and subsequently appealed.

Unfair Dismissal under the Fair Work Act

A previous Flag Post outlined when the Fair Work Act 2009 (FWA) provides that a person has been unfairly dismissed. At first instance the FWC found that the Appellant had not been unfairly dismissed as:

In summary terms, the aggregate of the Applicant’s conduct in relation to the failure to follow the lawful and reasonable directions - specifically the failure to attend the medical assessments - and his unreasonable refusal to participate in the disciplinary investigation formed a valid reason for dismissal.

On appeal the Appellant argued that the Respondent was not, as a matter of law, able to direct him to attend the medical assessments nor able to do so by way of a contractually-derived command as:

  • there was no basis on which to imply a further term into employment contract, because
  • the CMSH Act, associated regulations and agreement ‘covered the field’ in relation to medical assessments when returning to work from injury, and
  • those instruments did not specifically require the Appellant to attend a medical assessment with a doctor nominated by the Respondent.

Hence the directions were unlawful, and the dismissal unfair. The FWC rejected this argument, and found that the direction was lawful and reasonable.

The common law

The FWC noted that it has long been established at common law that employees must follow a direction given by their employer, provided it:

…relates to the subject matter of the employment and involves no illegality… In other words, the lawful commands of an employer which an employee must obey are those which fall within the scope of the contract of service and are reasonable.

The FWC concluded that the power to issue a direction that is lawful and reasonable is not limited to circumstances where it is founded on a positive rule of law or an express statutory provision. Put another way, the FWC was of the view that the common law allows employers to give a direction without a contractual or legislative basis, provided it is not illegal and relates to the subject matter of the employment.

Why is the case important?

The case builds on previous cases that have dealt with when an employer can (and cannot) direct an employee to attend a medical appointment with a specific practitioner, and also provides valuable insight into how the common law interacts with related statutory or contractual provisions.  However, the case should not be viewed as standing for a general proposition that every direction by an employer to an employee to attend a nominated medical practitioner will be reasonable. Whether such a direction is reasonable will largely turn on the circumstances of each case. For example, where an employee contracts a cold and takes personal leave (and does not have a history of excessive or regular use of personal leave for colds) it is unlikely that a direction to attend a specific doctor would be reasonable.


Thank you for your comment. If it does not require moderation, it will appear shortly.

Add your comment

[Click to expand]

We welcome your comments, or additional information which is relevant to a post. These can be added by clicking on the ‘Add your comment’ option above. Please note that the Parliamentary Library will moderate comments, and reserves the right not to publish comments that are inconsistent with the objectives of FlagPost. This includes spam, profanity and personal abuse, as well as comments that are factually incorrect or politically partisan. We will close comments after three months.




Captcha
Generate a new image
Type characters from the image:

Facebook LinkedIn Twitter Add | Email Print

FlagPost

Flagpost is a blog on current issues of interest to members of the Australian Parliament


Parliamentary Library Logo showing Information Analysis & Advice

Archive

Syndication

Tagcloud

Refugees asylum climate change immigration Australian foreign policy parliament social security welfare policy elections welfare reform school education health financing higher education Australian Defence Force emissions trading indigenous Australians women private health insurance people trafficking illicit drugs gambling health reform federal election 2010 United Nations Employment Asia disability income management Middle East Medicare Australian Bureau of Statistics statistics sport health forced labour federal budget Afghanistan Industrial Relations Carbon Pricing Mechanism politics dental health United States aid child protection environment poker machines Australia in the Asian Century Australian Sports Anti-Doping Agency steroids World Anti-Doping Agency National Disability Insurance Scheme detention aged care 43rd Parliament slavery health system Law Enforcement Australian Federal Police Criminal Law Fair Work Act Australian Public Service governance labour force people smuggling transport debt taxation international relations constitution New Zealand food WADA Australian Crime Commission pharmaceutical benefits scheme pensions public service reform children's health Aviation foreign debt gross debt net debt defence capability parliamentary procedure Senate Senators and Members ALP ASADA Newstart Parenting Payment multiculturalism Youth Allowance sea farers Higher Education Loan Program HECS federal state relations accountability Papua New Guinea youth paid parental leave same sex relationships corruption coal seam gas customs planning federal election 2013 Australian Electoral Commission doping OECD crime health risks International Women's Day Gonski Review of Funding for Schooling sex slavery Special Rapporteur Northern Territory Emergency Response social policy welfare ASIO intelligence community terrorist groups Australian Security Intelligence Organisation carbon tax mining High Court military history electoral reform employer employee renewable energy regional unemployment fishing European Union Federal Court family assistance skilled migration banking United Nations Security Council Australian economy forestry food labelling vocational education and training Drugs UK Parliament welfare systems Indonesia social media children Constitutional reform local government codes of conduct terrorist financing homelessness Parliamentary remuneration money laundering Trafficking in Persons Report energy science social inclusion human rights paternalism Australian Secret Intelligence Service sexual abuse terrorism World Trade Organization Australia public health China housing affordability bulk billing political parties water productivity health policy Governor-General US economy trade unions domestic violence export liquefied natural gas foreign bribery firearms question time speaker superannuation public housing election results by-election expertise public policy climate Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change leadership voting Department of Agriculture Fisheries and Forestry regulation Pacific Islands reserved seats research and development new psychoactive substances synthetic drugs UNODC carbon markets animal health middle class welfare ADRV Census Indigenous constitutional recognition of local government referendum consumer laws PISA competition policy royal commission US politics violence against women language education baby bonus Leaders of the Opposition citizen engagement policymaking Australia Greens servitude Trafficking Protocol forced marriage Population rural and regional mental health alcohol entitlements ministries Hung Parliament social citizenship maritime Iran transparency ANZUS regional students school chaplains federal budget 2011-12 salary Medicare Locals primary care Building the Education Revolution Scottish referendum early childhood education Middle East; national security; terrorism social services Criminal Code Amendment (Misrepresentation of Age to a Minor) Bill 2013 online grooming sexual assault of minors ACT Assembly national security smoking plain packaging tobacco cigarettes Asia; Japan; international relations Work Health and Safety Migration; asylum seekers; regional processing China; United States; international relations fiscal policy Racial Discrimination Act; social policy; human rights; indigenous Australians Foreign policy Southeast Asia Israel Palestine asylum refugees immigration political finance donations foreign aid disability employment Economics efficiency human rights; Racial Discrimination Act employment law bullying asylum seekers Animal law; food copyright Australian Law Reform Commission industry peace keeping contracts workplace policies same-sex marriage disorderly conduct integrity retirement Parliament House standing orders prime ministers election timetable sitting days First speech defence budget submarines workers financial sector Canada Somalia United Kingdom GDP Tasmania world heritage political engagement leave loading Trade; tariffs; safeguards; Anti-dumping public interest disclosure whistleblowing Productivity Commission limitation period universities Ireland cancer gene patents genetic testing suspension of standing and sessional orders live exports infant mortality honorary citizen railways disciplinary tribunals standard of proof World Health Organisation arts international students skilled graduate visas temporary employment visas apologies roads Italy national heritage NHMRC nutrition anti-dumping Rent Assistance obesity evidence law sacrament of confession US presidential election international days DFAT UN General Assembly deregulation Regulation Impact Statements administrative law small business Breaker Morant regional engagement social determinants of health abortion Members suspension workplace health and safety marine reserves hearing TAFE Victoria astronomy resources sector YMCA youth parliament Korea fuel rebate Australian Greens presidential nomination Racial Discrimination Act political parties preselection solar hot water Financial Action Taskforce Horn of Africa peacekeeping piracy Great Barrier Reef Stronger futures political financing political education Social Inclusion Board early childhood National Quality Framework for Early Childhood Education and Care Murray-Darling Basin sanctions Norway hospitals republic President Barack Obama Presidential visits qantas counselling Korean peninsula Work Choices biosecurity hendra environmental law federalism federation preselection therapeutic goods Therapeutic Goods Administration plebiscites computer games pests suicide nuclear COAG Ministerial Councils floods ADHD stimulant medication advertising electricity extradition standards conscience votes poverty preventative health rural health coastal erosion Parliamentary Budget Office NATO work-life balance

Show all
Show less